Not at all, for someone trying this for the first time you did great! My personal tips would be. I can fiddle around with the saturation more, is that basically your problem with the first set, it 'pops' too much? Thanks again! Also, do the eyes also stick out too much? It was hard for me to notice the eye color without the saturation, and I really like more visible eyes in my portraits, adds personality. I do agree that my edits take away from the more natural look Obsidian put in their portraits, but with the armor, I could only get the 'colorize' option to color the armor without any weird color fragments. Thanks for the tip! Honestly, I haven't touched photoshop (well, GIMP in this case) in like.~10 years, and even then I just made *really* crappy/amateur forum sigs, so I really have no clue what I'm doing. Try not to make it all one color especially if they are almost all midtones or highly saturated. My only suggestion would be to take caution when adding in the armor.
